“Don’t let the world around you squeeze you into its own mould, but let God re-mould your minds from within...”
Romans 12:2

No one logged in. Log in

Hilary's Desk

"Going Viral" - Gardasil fact or fiction?

Hilary Butler - Monday, April 13, 2015

This Sunday's SUNDAY programme called Going Viral, used national TV and Dr Miller to imply to children, "You can either get a vaccine, or you can get cancer."  Then the children sat there with Ian Sinclair saying, “The government should let us have this vaccine free.” The kids were so grateful for Dr Miller’s story.

But there is a huge problem with this unethical story.

Dr Andrew Miller said: “The initial biopsy showed there was a factor, a protein that was sitting inside the skin that actually is a marker for wart virus. So what's happened is I've got some sort of wart virus in my nose that's triggered off a cancer," he says.

He said I’ve got ****SOME SORT**** of wart virus in my nose.

This lack of clarity is a problem for several reasons:

What say the squamous cell carcinoma in Dr Miller’s nose… is NOT one covered by the vaccine?

Did you hear him say, “I’ve got HPV 6, 11, 16, or 18, and this squamous cell carcinoma could have been prevented by Gardasil.”?

As of August 2014, 178 different HPVs had been identified and grouped into five genera based on their L1 gene. Gardasil vaccine covers four viruses from one genus, - alphapapilloma types, 6, 11, 16, 18, which are mainly related to the genital area, and sometimes the mouth. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24850740

All the HPV genuses have a preference for different locations in the body. So the question is, are the strains in Gardasil relevant to the nose?

Gardasil HPV types are almost never found in the nose. The majority of nose HPV is beta and gamma papillomaviruses, not the L1 proteins represented in Gardasil. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23878325

As to Dr Miller vaccinating his three boys, it’s astonishing that he would do that to stop them experiencing what he has now got. HPV-related infections of any type take a very long time to convert to cancer.....

........And as we know, and Dr Miller said, “skin to skin” contact is all it takes to spread it......

.....So....... for the last 10+ years, Dr Miller has been kissing his wife and children, and it’s more than highly likely that his wife and children now have in their bodies, whatever type was in his nose. OR . . . they might, like the majority of other people, have just tossed it off and acquired natural immunity.

But it is illogical for his children to put their hands up for vaccination so that they won’t be like their Dad. ....  I will say it again, in case you missed it the first time..... They probably already have the genus and type which Dr Miller chose to have cut out, chemo’d and radiated.

So the whole flaw in this Sunday programme stems from lack of clarity about what SORT of wart virus it was in Dr Miller’s nose.

How would Ian Sinclair, and those Wellington High children (who were keen to go and be vaccinated after hearing from Dr Miller) feel, if they later found out that Dr Miller’s cancer was a genus which is not even related to the ones in the Gardasil vaccine?

Another question. Is it ethical to create fear in children as a result of giving information which lacks scientific clarity, or accuracy?

SUNDAY chose to take one doctor’s story, without proof of viral relevance and use it to influence children and a nation.

But nothing has been said about the growing list of girls who have been seriously hurt by this vaccine.

What’s worse, SUNDAY knows those girls exist and knows that those parents are just waiting for their stories to be heard.  So far the list of casualties from Gardasil far exceeds one doctor with a virus in his nose which might not even be a type in the vaccine.

Right at the start, the presenter said, that the show wasn’t about vaccination but about choice.

The problem was, that the whole show was about guilt and fear-mongering in order to get as many children to persuade their parents to vaccinate them as possible.

But CHOICE implies that you know all the information. 

SUNDAY, and Dr Andrew Miller, failed right at the foundation, because ***SOME SORT*** of wart virus doesn’t cut it, particularly when the Gardasil viruses are rarely if ever, found in the nose.
Bookmark and Share